Division II Woman Athlete of the Year Winners
| Name | School | Sport | Class |
|---|---|---|---|
| School: Lenoir-Rhyne | Sport: Track & Field | Class: 2025 | |
| School: Minnesota State University | Sport: Track & Field | Class: 2024 | |
| School: Minnesota Duluth | Sport: Basketball | Class: 2023 | |
| School: Shippensburg | Sport: Field Hockey | Class: 2022 | |
| School: Southwest Minnesota State | Sport: Volleyball | Class: 2019 | |
| School: Alaska Anchorage | Sport: Cross Country | Class: 2018 | |
| School: Merrimack | Sport: Track & Field | Class: 2017 | |
| School: Hillsdale | Sport: Track & Field | Class: 2016 | |
| School: Millersville (PA) | Sport: Field Hockey | Class: 2015 | |
| School: Bentley | Sport: Basketball | Class: 2014 | |
| School: Ashland | Sport: Basketball | Class: 2013, 2012 | |
| School: UMass-Lowell | Sport: Field Hockey | Class: 2011 | |
| School: Concordia | Sport: Volleyball | Class: 2010 | |
| School: Lock Haven | Sport: Softball | Class: 2009, 2006 | |
| School: Minnesota-Duluth | Sport: Volleyball | Class: 2008 | |
| School: Metropolitan State | Sport: Soccer | Class: 2007 | |
| School: Northern Kentucky | Sport: Softball | Class: 2005 | |
| School: Adams State | Sport: Soccer | Class: 2004 | |
| School: Christian Brothers | Sport: Soccer | Class: 2003 | |
| School: Cal State (LA) | Sport: Track & Field | Class: 2002 | |
| School: Truman State | Sport: Swimming & Diving | Class: 2001 | |
| School: North Dakota State | Sport: Basketball | Class: 2000 | |
| School: Regis | Sport: Volleyball | Class: 1999 | |
| School: California (PA) | Sport: Softball | Class: 1998 | |
| School: North Dakota State | Sport: Basketball | Class: 1997 | |
| School: Abilene Christian | Sport: Basketball | Class: 1996 | |
| School: Longwood | Sport: Golf | Class: 1995 | |
| School: Northern Michigan | Sport: Volleyball | Class: 1994 | |
| School: Pittsburg State | Sport: Cross Country | Class: 1993 | |
| School: Cal Poly State | Sport: Basketball | Class: 1992 | |
| School: Norfolk State | Sport: Basketball | Class: 1991 | |
| School: Delta State | Sport: Basketball | Class: 1990 | |
| School: North Dakota State | Sport: Volleyball | Class: 1989 | |
| School: Cal State Northridge | Sport: Volleyball | Class: 1988 |